DISREGARDED ENTITY impact on Canadian Tax Structuring

Contact Neufeld Legal for Canadian incorporation legal work at 403-400-4092 / 905-616-8864 or Chris@NeufeldLegal.com

The concept of a Disregarded Entity originates primarily from the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) "check-the-box" regulations in the United States. In the US context, a Disregarded Entity is an entity that is legally separate from its owner for liability purposes (such as a single-member Limited Liability Company, or LLC), but which is ignored for federal income tax purposes. This means that all income, deductions, losses, and credits of the entity flow directly through to its single owner, who reports them on their personal or corporate tax return, treating the entity's activities as if they were conducted directly. This feature grants the US taxpayer the benefit of flow-through taxation, which simplifies compliance and avoids the common double taxation inherent in corporate structures. This model of fiscal transparency is the baseline understanding of a Disregarded Entity in cross-border discussions.

The core of the Canadian tax issue with a disregarded entity lies in the stark contrast between US and Canadian entity classification. While the IRS views the entity as fiscally transparent, effectively looking past it to the owner, the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) takes the long-standing and firm position that a foreign limited liability company (such as a US LLC) must be treated as a corporation for the purposes of the Income Tax Act (Canada). This is because the CRA focuses on the legal characteristics of the entity, such as its perpetual existence, limited liability for its members, and separate legal personhood, which align it with the definition of a corporation under Canadian law. This fundamental difference in perspective, corporation in Canada versus flow-through in the US, is the source of nearly all the cross-border tax complications.

The direct result of this conflicting classification is the potential for severe double taxation for Canadian residents who hold an interest in a US disregarded entity. Since the US treats the entity as transparent, the Canadian owner is taxed in the US directly on their share of the entity’s income, often without receiving any cash distribution. However, when the Canadian owner files their Canadian return, the CRA treats the entity as a foreign corporation. This means the Canadian taxpayer is not deemed to have earned the underlying income and is therefore generally unable to claim a Foreign Tax Credit (FTC) for the US tax already paid. Later, when the entity actually distributes cash, the CRA taxes this distribution as a dividend from a foreign corporation, resulting in a second layer of Canadian tax on the same income stream.

The dual classification also severely restricts access to the benefits provided by the Canada-US Income Tax Convention (the Treaty). The Treaty is designed to mitigate double taxation between the two countries, but its benefits are generally only available to a "resident" of one of the contracting states who is liable to tax in that state. Because a disregarded entity is not liable for US federal income tax (as it is disregarded), the CRA denies the entity itself access to Treaty benefits. While changes have been made to the Treaty (specifically Article IV, Paragraph 6) to allow a "look-through" for US-resident members, Canadian-resident members often remain excluded, further exposing them to Canadian corporate tax rules and potentially punitive withholding taxes.

As such, for Canadian tax purposes, the concept of a Disregarded Entity is primarily a descriptor of a foreign entity's (usually US) treatment, rather than a recognized Canadian category of entity. The CRA firmly treats these hybrid structures as foreign corporations, completely nullifying the intended flow-through tax benefits for Canadian residents and instead introducing layers of complexity, onerous foreign reporting requirements (such as Form T1135 and T1134 in certain circumstances), and the significant risk of double taxation. Due to these pitfalls, utilizing a US LLC as a disregarded entity is almost universally considered an extremely tax-inefficient choice for Canadian residents and necessitates careful pre-emptive cross-border tax planning to avoid adverse consequences.

So, when you take a US LLC out of its most basic operational arrangement (operating exclusively within the United States), especially where it becomes part of a cross-border corporate arrangement with Canadian corporate entities, the legal and tax complexities are no longer straightforward and demand appropriate professional advice and strategic planning. As such, if your United States-based business enterprise is looking to undertake business in Canada, or is currently engaged in business in Canada, and requires incorporation-related legal services, contact our law firm at 403-400-4092 / 905-616-8864 or via email at Chris@NeufeldLegal.com.

Please Note: Our law firm's remote legal services are meticulously structured to meet or exceed all applicable provincial law society client identification and verification protocols, ensuring full compliance and robust protection against fraud and money laundering. Completing all required client identification and verification protocols is an absolute prerequisite for our providing any legal services, and we retain the right to discontinue the provision of legal services should any concern arise as to the legitimacy of the client or its business activities, at the sole and exclusive discretion of this law firm.